


Keep this in mind as you finish the game, or if you decide to play it again. No, she may not have the charisma of Ellie or Joel and may not be one of gaming’s all-time great characters, but she is the only thing saving this story from being a very dull, stock revenge tale, viewed entirely from Ellie’s side. I don’t think either are heroes, but I do not believe Abby deserves nearly the amount of hate that she’s getting as people play the game. But Ellie does much, much worse, shows far less mercy and causes much more collateral damage. But she returns home having lost her old, perfect life regardless because she simply couldn’t let what happened go. Her killing Abby in that moment instead of letting her go would have been the final nail in her coffin, and I’m glad she didn’t. This is why Ellie’s last-minute change of heart is her only redeeming moment and “makes sense” for the story. Again, perhaps still justified from her perspective, but still feeling like a villain to Abby. She’s a shell of her former self, and yet Ellie still wants to fight her after already killing all her friends and being spared by Abby twice. By the time Ellie reaches her, Abby has been imprisoned, likely abused in every possible way, for months. Abby injures Tommy and kills Jesse in this conflict, but how many “Jesse’s” did Ellie (and Tommy) kill by this point? Probably 5-6 alone in Abby’s close friend group, and dozens more in the larger WLF.Īnd what does Abby do once she gets the upper hand?Īnd what does Ellie do once Abby resurfaces, despite having an idyllic life with Dina and a new baby?ĭespite trying to redeem herself for her (pretty minimal) sins by saving Lev, Abby is once again cast into hell by the universe when she’s captured by the Rattler gang in California. Ellie is the clear villain from Abby’s perspective. So sure, by the time you reach the end of Abby’s section and you’re fighting Ellie as a “final boss,” it does make a lot of sense.


Not great.Īnd yet it’s also not mass murder, either.īy the end of Ellie’s section of the game when we switch back over to Abby, Ellie has killed:Īll of Abby’s friends, the former Fireflies that were there when Joel died.ĭozens, potentially hundreds of WLF members that for the most part, seem like fairly normal people who were veterans of the Seattle Civil War.Ībby’s ex Owen whom she clearly still loved, and Mel, who was pregnant.Īgain, at this point, Abby has killed nobody on Ellie’s side but Joel and did so for reasons that yes, could be considered pretty justified, given his murder of her father, all those Fireflies and the erasure of a potential cure. She has some friends, but is something of a controversial figure, and her complicated relationship with Mel and Owen does make her out to be kind of the bad guy in that trio, as she and Owen have sex while Mel is pregnant with his child and the two of them are together. In the events of the rest of the game Abby is yes, kind of an a-hole. When Joel instead just falls into her lap, she does kill him, brutally, but she intervenes to spare the life of Tommy and Ellie, who despite being loose ends, she has no specific quarrel with. At worst, she talks about intercepting a patrol and potentially roughing them up until they give up Joel. So yes, that alone certainly feels like enough reason to want to hunt down Joel.Ībby’s plan to find Joel does not involve storming Jackson and slaughtering anyone who gets in her way. And by doing this to save a single girl, he may have also doomed the entire human race since Ellie is the only immune person anyone has ever seen or heard of, and Abby’s father is the only person left alive (that we know of) who could have potentially derived a cure from her.
THE LAST OF US 2 CAST ABBY FULL
Not just that he killed her father, who appears to be a kind man who had to make a tough decision when Ellie showed up, but Joel butchered an entire hospital full of Fireflies, totally shattering Abby’s life. The entire impetus for Abby hunting down Joel is that he killed her father.
